Do teenagers care about charity?
December 22, 2008
Posted by CindyW in : Opinions & Thoughts , trackback
Last week I wrote about giving to charity in lieu of presents for our teenage nieces and nephews. My husband was of the opinion that teenagers would not care about any charity causes. I had some hope.
Here is the early report, as the nieces and nephews all got their charity gifts early (darn that thank-you email from the receiving organizations).
My fifteen year-old nephew who spends a lot of time surfing and thinking about surfing thought that the membership to the Surfrider Foundation was the coolest thing. In fact he found out that the Foundation had a local chapter on the island where he caught most of his waves. The fact it was founded by eco-minded surfers is way cool, dude.
Our horse crazy niece, to whom we gave a donation to the National Horse Protection League, was happy for a day. But she was saddened after learning on the website that nearly 100,000 horses were slaughtered for meat or sold to foreign countries for meat every year. I regret the gift somewhat. Is it fair for a twelve year old to learn the dark side of the world? Will it depress her or motivate her to learn more and act?
For our other niece, who thinks nothing when charging $500 to her mom’s credit card but is passionate about music and performing art, we donated to her community school of music and art. On the phone she told me that this was one of the most surprising presents she had ever received. “very cool” was her exactly words. I don’t think it can compete with the over-the-top presents she will get from her parents. Hopefully she will remember this one.
Nature conservancy membership went to our nephew who will embark on an international exchange program to Costa Rica next year. He called to say thank you. When asked whether he had checked out what the organization did, he said no but commented that he was glad someone was doing the conservation work in Costa Rica. “Hey, there are people who give money and there are people who do the work. I am definitely the former,” he half-joked.
I was ticked off, “Kid, you’ve got no money. What you have is all your parents’. So don’t you act like you are already a billionaire and throw money at all the problems.” I wanted to tell him that he missed the point of our donation for him - a chance for him to learn the various eco-hotspots in the world and what this wonderful organization was doing to preserve the biodiversity for his generations and beyond. But it seemed sort of pointless, as he has already adopted his parents’ world view.
Do teenagers care about charity? I’d venture to say yes if it is directly speaks to what they care about. Who knows, perhaps they will renew their membership/donation to these organizations and actually learn and act. One can always hope.
Happy Holidays!
CindyW at Organicpicks
If you enjoyed this entry, please subscribe to the Organic Picks Blog
Copyright 2007 Organicpicks





Find More Green Products & Reviews..
Comments»
I think you did well! All but one of the kids seemed to think the gift was “cool”, and it sounds like they can learn from the information they received, as well. I really think kids this age like to feel that they are tackling “grown up” problems, and most of them are pretty idealistic. I’m glad you were gutsy enough to take a new approach with them.
Kudos to you for being brave enough to give something intangible and meaningful. I’d say that if you touch at least one of those four kids, if just one of them decides to try to make a difference, you’ve achieved a big win. Merry Christmas.
What neat gifts! I would say that some of my cousin’s kids would think WOW! and some of them would say Great and then go on to the more tangible gifts they recieve- the difference is the parents some of my cousins definetely raise their kids to appreciate what they have and helping others is not a good thing to do but a responsibity, while the other cousins raise them to think “What is in it for me”. and guess which side gets the big gifts from cousin Rob???
Hi Cindy,
Enjoy your blog, hope you will still continue to post since we haven’t heard from you in awhile!
CLM
it’s nice to hear that your niece became interested with the foundation.we’re very lucky enough to get a lavish life and spending money or time at least with the less fortunate is equivalent to goodwill
Hi Cindy thanks for that retrospective post about teenagers. Yes, as you said I guess they do care about charity if it is about something they care. Of course we need to take into account their age and level of maturity before exposing them to the dark side of life sometimes. But on the whole I think the outcome would be positive in the long run.
Great thoughts!
Joost Hoogstrate